Madison: Mommy, why aren't we going to see Sara in the hospital today?
Me: Well, babies usually come out of your vagina but Sara had to have a c-section, which means they had to cut her tummy to get the baby out. So we are going to visit her tomorrow instead.
Madison: Oh. Mommy... I know how the baby gets out of Sara's tummy, but how did it get in there?
Dun, dun, dun...
Madison was a whole whopping 5 years old when she asked me the question all parents anticipate with fear. My awesome answer was "I am not comfortable talking to you about that right now, but when you are older I will tell you." and then I consulted my boss at the time who has a Ph. D. in Child Psychology. Her response was not very comforting. It made sense but did not make me less reluctant to tell my 5 year old about the birds and the bees.
The appropriate age to tell a child about sex and conception varies by each child, just like every other developmental milestone. Yes, being ready for "the talk" is a developmental milestone. The simple reason being that they have to gain the cognitive reasoning that tells them that women cannot just become pregnant. Pregnancy has to be a consequence of something... but what is it the consequence of? That's when you get hit with the question of where babies come from (or in my case, how they got in there in the first place). In my years in the classroom I have never been asked this question. In regards to my own pregnancy, I got asked how the baby is going to come out. I redirected them to their parents - you're welcome.
Even though my boss assured me it would be okay to tell Madison, so long as it was facts and not candy coated fibs (the stork, etc), I was not going to have that conversation with my 5 year old. The key here is HONESTY. My children understand me as an honest person, and I gave them my honest answer "I am not ready to talk to you about that right now. I will talk to you about it when you are older." So Madison asked me if she could know how babies get into mommies tummies on her 6th birthday. And her 7th birthday. And her 8th birthday. On her 6th and 7th birthday's I told her I still wasn't ready, but on her 8th birthday I told her I needed time to think about how I was going to talk to her about it, but that I would indeed tell her soon.
I don't recall how I began the conversation but it was just the two of us. No pictures. No graphic books. No videos. Just the two of us. And I told her the truth and used proper terminology. We didn't discuss pee pee's (we always use proper terminology in my home anyway so that wasn't a stretch). She already knew what a period was, but I reviewed the facts about the egg and the sperm. I talked about semen and ejaculation (I dislike that word!) and finally the birth of the baby.
Madison was thoroughly appalled. I asked her if she had any questions and she said no. I didn't believe her so I told her "You must have questions because that is a lot of information. I want you to ask me any questions that you can think of. Even if you think of them later." She finally came up with a question (within minutes):
"Do people like to have sex?"
I was not anticipating this!! I don't want to glorify sex to my 8 year old but I don't want to go back on one of the most important things I just told my daughter, which is "If you have any questions about sex, come to me and I will always tell you the truth about it." So I told her that people do enjoy sex and that it is something special that she should share with her husband. I left religious reasoning out because she may well decide not to be a religious person, but I think it is good practice regardless. Then the next question:
"Do you like having sex with Jesse?"
At this question I addressed the privacy part of sex. I told her that I would not talk to her about my own sex life and that it's not appropriate to ask people about their's, either. She understood that, but was not offended.
A couple of days later I readdressed the sex talk and asked her to tell me any additional questions she had come up with. I could have waited until she approached me but you can't be entirely sure that they are comfortable initiating the conversation, or even that they will know how. She had some more questions about sex but I don't recall what they were.
Madison turned 9 in May and has asked me more questions about sex when she thinks of them and we have so far covered, all of them were lead by questions she had:
- Birth control
- In-Vertro Fertilization
- Sexually Transmitted Diseases
- Things boys/girls say and do to try to have sex with you
- Body parts that are considered sexually attractive (the conventional ones)
- Inappropriate clothing
- Reason's it is important and/or a good idea to not have sex until you are married (religious and not religious reasons)
- Sexual terminology (thanks TV and radio)
- Words she hears at day care (she hasn't heard any at school)
- Signs of puberty
And I am sure the list will keep expanding. The key idea is honesty. Let your children know that you will always be honest; and initiate conversations often so that they don't feel like it is a taboo subject. One thing I didn't mention was that I told Madison not to discuss this with other children at school - even if another child had false information. We tall often about respecting other parents' choices for their children. Like that my friend tells her daughter that she will get pregnant if she kisses a boy. Madison knows that is not true but she doesn't say anything about it.
Be honest
Use facts
Initiate conversations often
Tell them you will be honest